Trainer Tom: A Motivation Drawback

I’ve instructed this story earlier than, but it surely bears repeating.

I as soon as randomly met a instructor from an area highschool at a social occasion. I knew that one in every of my younger kin, then a 15-year-old, attended the varsity, so naturally I discussed him.

The instructor shook his head, then stated, “I fear about that child.” 

I did not know the boy nicely, however I would been seeing him at household gatherings two or 3 times a 12 months for over a decade and I would by no means observed something to fret about. Sure, he was a bit “nerdy,” however within the completely finest sense of that phrase. I knew him as a boy of passions. It appeared like every time I spoke with him he was smitten by some new pastime or different — outer house, gathering knives, electrical trains, bicycles, taking part in guitar — all self-motivated. He was, in a nutshell, the kind of child this play-based educator did not fear about within the least.

Once I requested his instructor for extra, he answered that he was “too quiet” and “shut in,” that he did not appear notably engaged with college, and that he had a “motivation downside.”

I countered by telling him concerning the intellectually curious boy I knew.

“I had no thought,” the instructor stated, “I want he’d divulge heart’s contents to me!”

As luck would have it, I noticed the boy every week or so later, I shared what his instructor had instructed me, saying, “I believe he simply desires to know the actual you.”

The boy grimaced. “I do not need my academics to know something about me. In the event that they know what I like, they will use it in opposition to me.” He defined, “At any time when academics know what a child likes, they attempt to take it away and use it as, like, a reward for good grades or one thing.” 

In my very own thoughts, I added, Or threaten to take it away as a punishment. 

It was a eager perception. I did not attempt to speak him out of it.

I used to be reminded of him yesterday when a reader commented on one in every of my posts from earlier this week. Her son’s IEP (Individualized Schooling Program) calls for normal “motion breaks.” She’s just lately realized that his academics had been dangling these mandated breaks as a “reward” for finishing this or that task. Now, I do not know the regulation the place she lives, however in lots of locations an IEP is a authorized doc. Withholding motion from anybody needs to be felony, however on this case it very nicely may be.

And lest you suppose this can be a one-off, each day younger youngsters are having their recess time — their free motion time — taken away or curtailed for the exact same motive. Certainly one of my former preschool college students had his “out of doors time” revoked as a result of, as his instructor stated, “He will not sit nonetheless in school.” Motion isn’t a alternative. It is a necessity. There has by no means been a scientific examine finished that finds that holding a physique nonetheless improves cognitive operate. Certainly, the analysis finds simply the alternative: each human ever examined thinks extra clearly whereas their physique is in movement. An educator who restricts a baby’s motion is not after pondering, they’re after obedience, which is pondering’s reverse.

As my younger relative discovered for himself, customary faculties are so hooked on rewards and punishments that they’re “nervous about” self-directed learners. They’re so dedicated to carrots and sticks that they merely can conceive of a kid who’s motivated from inside. Our faculties are so afraid of kids truly pondering for themselves that they deal with even that — free thought — as a type of stimulus-response behaviorist device. As soon as you have obeyed me, I am going to allow you to suppose. Once I ring this bell, you’ll drool.

What an unbelievable waste of childhood. What an unbelievable waste of life. The final time I touched base with my younger relative he was off on his motorbike for a weekend of mountaineering together with his girlfriend. 

I’ve by no means taught a baby who was not a self-motivated learner. I’ve by no means been tempted by rewards and punishments. Our play-based preschools are fashions of the best way faculties may very well be. 

******

I have been writing about play-based studying nearly each day for the previous 14 years. I’ve just lately gone again by way of the 4000+ weblog posts(!) I’ve written since 2009. Listed here are my 10 favourite in a nifty free obtain. Click on right here to get yours.

I put plenty of effort and time into this weblog. If you would like to assist me please take into account a small contribution to the trigger. Thanks!